Kentucky Judge Orders Bond Hearing for Detained Green Card Holder

Kentucky Judge Orders Bond Hearing for Detained Green Card Holder

A federal judge in Kentucky has ordered a bond hearing for Beata Siemionkowicz, an Illinois green card holder detained by ICE for over a year. The hearing is scheduled for this Thursday.

Siemionkowicz, a 57-year-old mother from Round Lake, Illinois, filed a habeas corpus petition in early September. United States District Judge Karen Caldwell granted her request, citing due process violations in Siemionkowicz’s detention. ACLU of Illinois attorney Hirsh Joshi highlighted the rarity of such hearings for mandatorily detained individuals in this district.

This case highlights broader issues related to mandatory ICE detention without bond hearings. Siemionkowicz’s potential release might inspire similar cases in Kentucky’s district, where many detainees lack initial hearings despite prolonged detention.

ICE spokespersons stated that custody decisions are made daily based on legal requirements and ensuring attendance at immigration proceedings. ICE arrested Siemionkowicz in August 2025 due to previous misdemeanors and alleged document forgery in 2001. Her family claims she already served her sentence for past offenses, taken during a challenging divorce period.

Siemionkowicz, a legal U.S. entrant since 1995 and green card holder since 2003, adjusted to life as a caregiver in Round Lake. Her abrupt arrest led to widespread attention and calls for reform in handling such cases.

The Supreme Court plans to review a Trump-era policy on bond hearings, potentially affecting Siemionkowicz and others with prolonged detentions. Joshi remarked that upcoming decisions could change access to bond hearings without predicting Supreme Court involvement in this specific case.

A favorable bond hearing decision allows Siemionkowicz to contest her December 9, 2025 deportation order outside detention, amid family support, while her daughter, Gabi, remains cautiously hopeful. Recent developments raised concerns about her treatment in the Campbell County Detention Center, prompting a congressional investigation into facility conditions.

Joshi emphasized the urgency of Siemionkowicz’s release due to worsening conditions at the detention center. Ongoing attention from officials and media may impact the outcome and future handling of similar cases.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *