AI Gun Detection System Faces Scrutiny After Incident at Maryland School

AI Gun Detection System Faces Scrutiny After Incident at Maryland School

An AI system designed to detect guns in schools is under scrutiny after four teenagers were reportedly detained at gunpoint over a misidentified bag of Doritos. The incident occurred despite the original alert being canceled. The students have filed a lawsuit against Omnilert, a security technology firm, Baltimore County school officials, and police officers following an event on October 20, 2025, outside Kenwood High School in Maryland. The complaint claims officers arrived with guns drawn, ordered the teens to kneel, handcuffed, and searched them.

One of the students, Taki Allen, was eating Cool Ranch Doritos while waiting with friends for a ride home after football practice. This incident has sparked concerns about the reliability of AI in gun detection systems and the response of schools and police when such systems issue false alarms.

What Is Omnilert and How Does It Operate?

Omnilert is a security company based in Virginia. Its Gun Detect software employs AI to scan footage from existing surveillance cameras for objects that resemble firearms. When a potential weapon is identified, the system evaluates the threat. Alerts meeting a defined threshold are reviewed by Omnilert’s monitoring staff before being forwarded to school security personnel. These notifications may include video footage, enlarged images highlighting the suspect object, and details about the alert’s status. School officials then decide if the threat requires police action. The system is also capable of alerting designated law enforcement personnel.

According to Omnilert, the system aims to identify visible firearms before shots are fired, offering schools additional time to react. The software focuses on objects rather than employing facial recognition technology.

Extent of Omnilert’s Use

Omnilert claims its technology has been implemented in over 600 schools across 50 districts, as reported by Courthouse News Service. Baltimore County Public Schools adopted the system in 2023, installing it in all 165 schools by spring 2024. The technology integrates with more than 7,000 existing security cameras in the district.

The Maryland Office of the Inspector General for Education noted that Baltimore County spends $560,000 annually on Omnilert’s services, approximately $5.09 per student each year. Other districts using Omnilert technology include Uvalde, Texas, and Nashville, Tennessee. Omnilert also markets its services to hospitals and businesses.

How Accurate Is Omnilert?

The students’ lawsuit questions Omnilert’s claims regarding the reliability of its gun-detection system, alleging that over 99% of alerts in Baltimore County were false positives. These claims are based on a November 2025 investigation by Maryland’s Office of the Inspector General for Education.

The inspector general’s report provided more details, indicating that Omnilert’s monitoring system dismissed 96% of objects initially flagged by the software without further action. Of the alerts sent to Baltimore County schools between November 2023 and November 2025, less than 1% needed police intervention. However, this does not mean that the software incorrectly identified firearms 99% of the time. Some alerts involved replica weapons or objects necessitating further scrutiny.

The inspector general noted that the system did not confuse a blue bag of chips for a gun. Rather, the alert was triggered by a student’s hand movements, the object’s position, and its reflective nature. The software estimated a 90% probability of a firearm presence. Omnilert staff reviewed the alert, forwarding it to school officials and police, although it was canceled before officers arrived.

Reason for Student Detention After Alert Cancellation

Baltimore County Public Schools reported that Omnilert issued an alert at 7:04 p.m. on October 20, 2025. By 7:06 p.m., designated safety officers and a police representative reviewed the images, determined there was no threat, and canceled the alert. However, at 7:17 p.m., Kenwood High School Principal Catherine Smith contacted the school’s resource officer after reviewing the initial alert. The officer contacted the local police precinct, and the first officer arrived at 7:23 p.m.

The lawsuit claims that the principal did not recognize the cancellation notice and sent a screenshot of the original footage to the school officer, leading to the armed response. The inspector general identified potential flaws in the alert system that could contribute to such errors, including enlarged images or video viewed on phones causing users to miss cancellation messages. Investigators found procedural weaknesses in schools allowing previously canceled alerts to be treated as potential active threats by the police.

The inspector recommended adjusting notification procedures and providing additional training for staff. Baltimore County Public Schools and the police department acknowledged the need for improvements and committed to offering more training.

Newsweek has reached out to Omnilert, Baltimore County Public Schools, Baltimore County Police, and the Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law for remarks.

Other Complaints Against Omnilert

Omnilert is also facing a lawsuit for its alleged failure to detect a gun during a fatal shooting at Antioch High School in Nashville, Tennessee, in January 2025. A student wounded in the incident filed the lawsuit in May 2026 against Omnilert and the company responsible for installing and maintaining the system.

The complaint argues that the system failed to identify the shooter’s handgun before shots were fired, resulting in the death of 16-year-old Josselin Corea Escalante. The 17-year-old gunman died from a self-inflicted gunshot wound. The lawsuit claims Omnilert did not sufficiently communicate the limitations regarding camera placement, lighting, distance, and weapon visibility. These allegations have not yet been proven in court.

What’s Next?

The Maryland students are seeking compensatory and punitive damages and a court order to halt the use of Omnilert until better verification procedures and training are implemented. Their lawsuit claims constitutional rights violations, unreasonable searches, and seizures, negligence, and false imprisonment.

Omnilert previously stated its system worked as intended during the Kenwood incident, detecting a possible threat and passing it for human assessment. The school district and police department defended the initial alert process while acknowledging issues with managing the canceled alert.

Newsweek produced this story with AI assistance and invited readers to contact their editors for more details.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *