Last week, Karmelo Anthony was convicted and sentenced to 35 years in prison for the fatal stabbing of Frisco teenager Austin Metcalf during a high school track meet. Newly released court documents offer insight into the evidence considered by jurors in reaching their verdict.
Events Leading up to the Fatal Stabbing
Hours before the incident on April 2, 2025, Anthony’s girlfriend, Valeria Torres Perez, reported him to school staff for allegedly stalking her. She described Anthony texting her about being ‘on the verge,’ a statement whose meaning remains unspecified. Torres highlighted how Anthony was driving by her home, refusing to let her end their relationship.
“I’m lowk on the verge,” Anthony wrote in text messages to Torres.
Prosecutors’ Notice of Prior Conduct
The court document outlines numerous past acts Anthony allegedly committed, including threats, assaults, and discussions about weapons and robberies. While it does not establish these actions definitively, the notice suggests they might have been relevant to the case. Throughout 2024 and early 2025, Anthony’s communications often included gun-related threats.
For example, in May 2024, Anthony is alleged to have threatened to shoot multiple people, according to text exchanges with Torres. He reportedly asked her, “how many bullets you want coming out of your chest.” Further messages indicated Anthony’s possession of a firearm and included threats involving guns.
Prosecutors also allege Anthony’s involvement in robberies and fighting, including a suspension for fighting in February 2025.
Attempts for a New Trial and Appeal
Following his conviction, Anthony sought a new trial, although the judge denied it. The appeals process is underway according to reports.
The released documents do not specify any formal mental-health diagnosis for Anthony. Instead, they depict the prosecution’s view of Anthony’s behavioral history as potentially indicative of his actions.
As the appeal proceeds, these insights into Anthony’s past could continue to play a significant role. His attorney’s comments are awaited for further clarification.