Days after November 3, Alaska’s Senate race remains unresolved. Democrat Mary Peltola’s campaign has filed a lawsuit on Friday against Alaska election officials. The lawsuit seeks immediate access to information on absentee ballots rejected during this tightly contested election. The campaign insists that transparency is essential to ensure all eligible votes are counted, maintaining the race’s integrity. This election has faced challenges due to a namesake contender against the incumbent, Republican Senator Dan Sullivan.
The Justice Department previously sued Alaska’s election officials, aiming to prevent race certification if the incumbent lost, and votes for Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. were crucial to the incumbent’s victory. However, this lawsuit was dismissed by a state judge on November 1, shortly before Election Day.
The race remains exceedingly close, with only 600 votes separating Peltola and Sullivan. Some believe the outcome could depend on a few ballots sent by mail or from remote areas. Alaska will count ballots from overseas voters up to and including November 18.
In another closely contested U.S. Senate race in Mississippi, Republican Cindy Hyde-Smith is preparing for possible litigation. Her team demands provisional ballots be set aside to verify their eligibility and final disposition.
An attorney letter, dated November 5, states, “These measures are necessary to ensure that each affidavit ballot’s eligibility for counting, and ultimate disposition can be verified.”
Meanwhile, in California, the federal government dropped its lawsuit against the state over 20,000 mail-in ballots. These ballots were purportedly cast by non-U.S. citizens. California Attorney General Rob Bonta announced the lawsuit’s withdrawal on Friday, marking it as a state victory.
Mary Peltola’s Lawsuit Explained
On Friday, Peltola’s campaign group, Alaskans for Mary, filed a lawsuit against the Alaska Division of Elections. This also involves Lieutenant Governor Nancy Dahlstrom and Director of Elections Carol Beecher regarding the absentee ballots rejected in the November 3 election.
The lawsuit requests information on why these ballots were rejected, stating, “Plaintiff cannot ensure that its voters’ lawful votes were properly counted without knowing whose absentee ballots were rejected or questioned, and why.” Despite requesting records on October 27, no responses were received.
On November 4, further communication demanded records by the next day. The request was denied, as indicated in the lawsuit.
Without these records, Peltola’s campaign argues they cannot verify whether ballots are accurately counted or if votes for Peltola are wrongfully dismissed. The advancing deadlines create pressure to secure these records.
The lawsuit seeks emergency relief from an Anchorage court, including a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction to release the records.
Why Alaska’s Division of Elections Has Denied Access
The state Department of Law, representing the officials, stated on Friday that records are confidential due to their preliminary and changeable nature. Providing these records separately or allowing observer retention is against established practices, they claimed. Release, they argue, could complicate ballot processing and delay vote counting.
The Department involved Newsweek in the conversation alongside Peltola’s and Sullivan’s campaigns for further comments.
Mary Peltola vs. Dan Sullivan: Election Status
As of Saturday, over 20 percent of votes remain uncounted with Peltola narrowly leading Sullivan at 48.2 percent to 47.9 percent. Republican Gerald Heikes and undeclared candidate Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. have lesser percentages. Allegations state Sullivan Jr. ran as a decoy to siphon votes from the incumbent. The result may take days if neither leading candidate achieves a majority.
Ranked choice tabulation will occur fifteen days post-election.
Assistant Professor Russell Luke noted this reflects the vastness of the state and its electoral methods. Delay might mean the nation awaits Alaska’s results for Senate control.
Cindy Hyde-Smith vs. Scott Colom: Election Update
In Mississippi, Hyde-Smith trails Democrat Scott Colom by nearly 2,000 votes. With 97 percent of votes tallied, Hyde-Smith carries 48.8 percent while Colom leads with 49.1 percent. Independent candidate Ty Pinkins has 2.1 percent.
Victory for Colom, currently a local prosecutor, would break historic grounds in Mississippi as the first Black senator since post-Civil War Reconstruction. Hyde-Smith, controversially dubbed a Trump pick, would suffer another loss if the current trend survives.
The result is forecasted before Alaska’s. Mississippi won’t hold runoffs; votes must finalize by November 10. Hyde-Smith’s lawyers insist on preserving ballot documentation securely for potential legal proceedings.
