A Long Island man, David Agtsteribbe, 58, faces serious accusations after being charged with impersonating a combat veteran. Authorities revealed he had been discharged for bad conduct and accused him of misappropriating $81,000 from a veterans’ group.
Agtsteribbe falsely claimed to have received a Purple Heart, presenting himself as a wounded war hero. His arrest was announced by the Suffolk County District Attorney’s Office, just before Veterans Day. Prosecutors detailed that Agtsteribbe was discharged in 1988 as a private after being court-martialed for stealing from a fellow soldier.
Deception and Theft
Prosecutors allege Agtsteribbe altered his discharge documents, falsely representing a distinguished military record. These forged papers helped him become a finance officer at a veterans’ group, where he reportedly misused funds for personal expenses.
Fabricating military achievements is particularly despicable,” said District Attorney Raymond A. Tierney. “Agtsteribbe allegedly exploited veterans’ sacrifices for personal gain, betraying their trust and our prosecution will seek justice.
A table displayed Agtsteribbe’s allegedly fake military awards during a news conference.
Misuse of Veterans’ Benefits
Agtsteribbe joined the Hampton Bays American Legion in 2021 by falsifying discharge documents. The altered records also reflected a higher military status, possibly granting him undeserved health care and privileges.
Starting in 2022, he allegedly funneled organization funds into his personal account, covering expenses such as Amazon purchases, bills, leisure activities, and travel. Prosecutors calculated a total theft of $81,798.31.
Agtsteribbe’s falsified documents reportedly allowed him membership in several veterans’ organizations since 2019.
In 2023 and 2024, he allegedly filed fake discharge paperwork with the Town of Southampton to bypass a $50 parking permit fee and secure a handicap parking permit. Some documents falsely identified him as a retired lieutenant colonel.
Legal Consequences
Agtsteribbe faces multiple charges, including grand larceny, criminal possession of a forged instrument, and falsifying business records. A conviction could lead to 25 years to life in prison as a persistent felony offender. Prosecutors requested substantial bail, citing his criminal history and current charges, with $100,000 cash or other secured bonds to ensure his court return. His next court appearance is scheduled for November 13, 2026.
