Rabbi Ari Berman, President of Yeshiva University, recently discussed the growing concern of antisemitism in New York City. This follows a hate crime incident at a synagogue in Manhattan. Berman highlighted the extensive security measures being put in place as classes begin, citing data that reports 860 incidents in the city and nearly 1,200 statewide.
As the Jewish New Year, Rosh Hashanah, approached, synagogues across the nation prepared to welcome congregants with heightened security. This underscores how post-9/11 America has intensified security at Jewish places of worship. Eric Fingerhut of Jewish Federations of North America noted the shift after 9/11 when Jewish communities realized the necessity of protection beyond simple police presence during high holidays.
The Jewish community understood clearly that the same hate targeting America on 9/11 also had deep-rooted animus towards Jewish people.
This led to the creation of the Secure Community Network, offering a centralized security model and coordination with federal law enforcement. Today, Rosh Hashanah preparations extend to include secured entrances and trained congregants.
The financial burden of this new reality is significant. A study found Jewish institutions spend about $1 billion annually on security. Security is no longer exclusive to major cities. Training has equipped more than 20,000 people in recent years to protect worshippers nationwide.
Michael Masters, CEO of the Secure Community Network, highlighted the increasing threat environment yet emphasized community preparedness. In 2025 alone, SCN recorded numerous incidents and trained thousands, emphasizing coordinated security effort. The FBI reported over 1,500 incidents targeting Jews, reflecting the disproportionate risk they face.
Crime statistics in New York for 2026 showed overall crime fell, but hate crimes against Jews rose by 8%. The NYPD will intensify security during high holidays in response to ongoing threats.
Significant security incidents in recent years, such as attacks on synagogues in Michigan and New York, reinforce the need for vigilance. Steven Ingber of the Jewish Federation of Detroit states their community remains vigilant but confident during times of celebration.
Rabbi Aaron Starr expressed heightened anxieties as communities navigate ongoing threats. However, security costs continue to weigh heavily, with annual expenses for a single guard estimated at $90,000. Assistance through federal support remains a priority for community leaders.
Eric Fingerhut asserted that security aims to prevent attacks and allow continued participation in Jewish life without fear. The presence of security measures should ensure safety, enabling Jewish communities to celebrate with confidence.
Experts insist on the importance of security to enable the practice of Jewish traditions. The goal is to maintain a place for Jewish life, rather than create fortresses out of synagogues.
Journalist Ariella Noveck covers antisemitism and Middle East affairs. Follow her on social media for more insights.