Improv comedy thrives on the idea that mistakes are opportunities for creativity. In Chicago, this mindset extends beyond the stage for Farrell Walsh, the artistic and managing director of CIC Theater. He views setbacks as chances to evaluate the theater’s direction, handling each challenge as it comes.
Disastermight seem exaggerated for a theater focused on silliness, but improv rarely deals in subtleties.
Walsh has led CIC on a journey to secure a new permanent space after leaving their long-term home on 1422 W. Irving Park Road in 2022. His involvement dates back to the early 2000s as a performer and later as the artistic director. CIC, known for its improvised and sketch shows, moved to Irving Park after originally performing at The Cornservatory on Lincoln Avenue. When COVID-19 hit, the company faced new challenges when the building’s ownership changed in 2022, prompting a return to their nomadic roots.
In late 2022, CIC struck an agreement with Finley Dunne’s Tavern, allowing performances in the bar’s backroom twice a week. These evenings featured a mix of student teams, guest performers, and an open-stage format for all aspiring performers. Despite changes, CIC maintained its improv classes to foster community and keep momentum going.
CIC prides itself on community. While not as widely recognized as iO or The Second City, it focuses on innovative approaches. Instead of distinct scenes, a CIC show weaves previous elements into new ones, maintaining momentum without constant resets. This approach requires skill and offers a seamless flow between scenes.
In late 2025, CIC ended its arrangement with Finley Dunne’s and began searching for a new venue. After exploring many possibilities, Walsh identified a potential space at 4301 N. Western Avenue, previously the Celtic Crown. This new venue offered the combination bar-and-theater space they desired.
In collaboration with Kyle McCabe, a former bar manager, they launched The Western Bar & Kitchen in July 2025. This new home is a Southwest-inspired tavern, reminiscent of Walsh’s time in Arizona. Nearly a year later, CIC is set to invite the community back into its revamped theatrical space.
Support from the community has been vital. A successful GoFundMe campaign exceeded its $25,000 goal, demonstrating strong backing from local improvisers and supporters. With classes ongoing and dining thriving at The Western, the anticipation builds for the grand opening. CIC remains confident that thanks to the community’s unwavering support, an empty audience is unlikely.
Ryan P.C. Trimble is a freelance writer.