President Donald Trump’s chance to appoint another Supreme Court nominee seems over, as Democrats have secured a Senate majority, potentially blocking any nominee he selects during the second half of his term. Legal experts shared their insights with Newsweek.
Midterm Election Outcomes
Democrats are winning at least seven Senate seats, specifically in Iowa, Kansas, Maine, North Carolina, Ohio, South Carolina, and Texas. Races in Alaska and Mississippi remain uncertain. A Democratic Senate shifts the landscape significantly regarding Supreme Court appointments. If any of the nine seats opens in the next two years, any Trump nominee would require Senate confirmation, which Democrats may block.
The Partisan Nature of Supreme Court Confirmations
Historically, judicial confirmations enjoyed bipartisan support; the process has become increasingly partisan. The fight over Justice Merrick Garland’s 2016 confirmation, after Justice Antonin Scalia’s passing, transformed the confirmation landscape. Republicans delayed, hoping for a Republican win, allowing Trump to appoint Justice Neil Gorsuch in 2017. In 2020, Justice Amy Coney Barrett’s confirmation after Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s death fueled further partisan tensions, as Democrats invoked the 2016 precedent against an election-year appointment. Trump had earlier appointed Justice Brett Kavanaugh.
Challenges for Trump in His Second Term
During Trump’s second term, appointing more justices has been elusive. Some Republicans wished for older conservative justices, like Justice Samuel Alito or Justice Clarence Thomas, to retire before the midterms to let Trump appoint newer, younger conservatives. However, neither has signaled retirement plans. Now, with a looming Democratic Senate through 2027, Trump’s chance to appoint further conservative justices diminishes.
Democrats’ Power to Block
Democrats will control at least 54 Senate seats come January, enabling them to block Trump nominees. Daniel Urman, a Northeastern University law professor, stated Democrats would likely block a nominee if Trump attempted a 2026 retirement replacement. This resistance reflects on past practices when, after Scalia’s death, the Supreme Court sought compromise due to a similar situation.
Urman noted the slim possibility of Trump negotiating for a moderate pick, given his insistence on loyalty among justices. Republicans are already concerned over their reduced influence, as Florida Governor Ron DeSantis indicated, noting the Republicans’ potential lack of opportunities to confirm future justices.
Potential Lame Duck Session Retirements
Some suggest a justice retirement before year-end, like Samuel Alito, could allow Republicans to confirm a justice in the current session. However, Paul Collins, a professor of legal studies and political science, calls a retirement for political reasons unprecedented. The Democrats’ incoming tenure diminishes Trump’s appointment odds.
If any retirements occur early, aggressive Supreme Court reform, including expansion and term limits, becomes likely, according to Collins and Urman. Such moves could further politicize the Court, reducing public trust in its decisions.
Conservative Justice Legacy Considerations
Justice Clarence Thomas, another conservative, contemplates his legacy beyond Trump’s potential ability to appoint successors. He could set a record for longest-serving justice by May 2028, compelling him to remain. Stephen Wermiel, a professor at American University, expressed doubt that Thomas would retire prematurely, knowing any Trump nominee might face Senate resistance.
Potential Supreme Court Reform
The Democratic Senate presence might pressure reform ideas regarding Supreme Court operations, like term limits and stricter ethics codes. Public trust in the Court remains low, as a Gallup poll showed only 34 percent approval in September 2026.
Though Democrats lack a veto-proof majority for reforms, their efforts reflect a demand among the public for Supreme Court change. Trump’s veto power remains a significant hurdle for any reform passage without bipartisan support.
Contact Newsweek editors about this story: Jason Lemon and Gray R. Thomas.
