William Pullinsi, a central figure in the creation of the American dinner theater experience, passed away on May 17 at his home in Dyer, Indiana, at age 86. Tony D’Angelo, his longtime partner at Candlelight Dinner Playhouse, announced his death. ‘We worked together for 70 years,’ D’Angelo shared, emphasizing Pullinsi’s view of his colleagues as family.
Pullinsi is often celebrated for his significant contributions to the theater world through the Candlelight Dinner Playhouse in Summit, a southwest suburb of Chicago. It was during the time when Jim Jacobs, writer and actor, wrote ‘Grease’ in Candlelight’s green room, showcasing the influence Pullinsi had on budding talents. Over his career, Pullinsi directed more than 400 shows, primarily in the Chicago area.
Born in September 1939 and raised in Summit, Pullinsi was known not just for his directing skills but also for launching the careers of renowned actors such as Mandy Patinkin, Joe Mantegna, and Shelley Long. In 1959, Pullinsi and D’Angelo opened their first Candlelight Theatre in Washington, D.C. ‘We offered people dinner and a show for $3.95,’ D’Angelo recalled. Encouraged by this success, they moved their venture to Chicago in 1961, establishing ‘The Original Dinner Playhouse’.
Unpretentious and affordably glamorous, Candlelight became a vital part of Chicagoland’s culture.
The theater, initially located at 5508 S. Archer Ave., was on land owned by Pullinsi’s grandfather. In 1964, the venue was relocated to 5620 S. Harlem Ave., a 550-seat theater. This move solidified Pullinsi’s reputation as a serious theatrical producer. The Forum Theatre, added in 1973, allowed for diverse productions without table service.
At the Candlelight, patrons enjoyed cocktails, appetizers, and meals like prime rib as waiters served them before performances. Thanks to D’Angelo’s expertise as an electrical engineer, the theater was equipped with advanced stage technology. Unfortunately, the theater closed in 1997 after a loan was called in, surprising many devoted followers.
Throughout his life, Pullinsi remained a resident of Evanston, attending St. Joseph School, Benet Academy, and later pursuing graduate studies. He received an honorary doctorate from Lewis University and served as the artistic director of the now-closed Theatre at the Center in Munster, Indiana. Pullinsi retired in 2015, acknowledged as Chicagoan of the Year in Theater by the Tribune.
Noreen Heron, who began her career under Pullinsi, emphasized his role in launching many careers. Michael Weber, from Porchlight Music Theatre, praised Pullinsi for giving audiences a broader theatrical experience. Pullinsi’s influence extended beyond Chicago, with many productions going national.
William Pullinsi leaves behind his son, Jamie Pullinsi, and former wife, Ami Silvestre. Funeral services are still being arranged.