In a clubhouse filled with notable talents earning landmark salaries, Dave Roberts delivered a crucial message. During his speech in Cincinnati, Roberts chose not to highlight stars like Shohei Ohtani, Freddie Freeman, or Mookie Betts. Instead, he focused on those who often remain in the shadows.
Roberts emphasized the importance of being ready to be ‘That Guy’—the unsung hero who emerges to make a pivotal play, whether it’s hitting a crucial run, pitching a vital inning, or catching a game-saving ball. This ethos was shared with a group anxiously preparing for postseason glory.
The Dodgers exemplified the impact of these unexpected heroes in the previous season’s Game 7 World Series win over the Toronto Blue Jays, thanks to Miguel Rojas and Andy Pages. Rojas tied the game with a home run after a 44-day drought, while Pages made an incredible catch despite earlier struggles.
Such moments define the Dodgers’ legacy; it’s not always the superstars who lead the team to victory but often those one-hit wonders who step up in essential moments.
The Dodgers’ postseason magic is filled with these surprise contributors. From Kiké Hernández setting the tone in the 2024 division series to Austin Barnes’ historic World Series play in 2020, these anecdotes are legendary. Notable moments include Mickey Hatcher’s daring plays, José Lima’s shutout in 2004, and Jay Johnstone’s pinch-hit homer in 1981.
As Roberts stated, a three-peat requires one of these unexpected players to rise to the occasion. Here are the candidates to be ‘That Guy’ for the 2026 season:
Josue De Paula
Josue De Paula, a Dodgers right fielder, is a top contender. Known for his swagger and style, the 21-year-old came from double A to temporarily replace Ohtani. In 11 games, he amassed 10 hits, a homer, seven RBIs, and an OPS of 1.081, showcasing his readiness for an October breakthrough.
Kyle Tucker
Kyle Tucker, despite earning $60 million annually, struggled throughout the season yet has recently found his form with a .969 OPS and key at-bats. Tucker seems poised for redemption come October.
Edwin Díaz
While plagued by injuries, Edwin Díaz has shown promise with a scoreless inning in a recent rehab assignment. As a former top closer, Díaz might reclaim his success during high-pressure postseason moments.
Emmet Sheehan
Emmet Sheehan, another possibility, has demonstrated potential with significant September performances. His ability to pitch crucial relief innings makes him a viable candidate for a pivotal October role.
Hunter Feduccia
Backup catcher Hunter Feduccia possesses qualities essential for being ‘That Guy.’ His toughness and keen eye, evidenced by his high ABS challenge success rate, position him for a surprising postseason contribution.
The identity of ‘That Guy’ remains unknown, but the Dodgers’ quest for a three-peat hinges on newcomers stepping into the spotlight. As illustrated by Rojas and Pages last October, the surprise hero is around the corner.