The recent World Cup match between Curaçao and Germany caused a stir as the smallest nation by population to qualify for the tournament faced the four-time champion. Curaçao’s Livano Comenencia scored an equalizing goal, sparking hope for a potential upset. However, momentum shifted after a hydration break. Curaçao conceded two goals before halftime, ultimately losing 7-1.
The introduction of hydration breaks by FIFA, aimed at helping players cope with summer heat in the United States, Canada, and Mexico, has sparked debate. Critics argue they disrupt the game’s flow and allow coaches to provide tactical instructions. Former England striker Alan Shearer expressed sympathy for Curaçao, noting the break halted their momentum.
Hydration breaks, held midway through each half, have led to shifts in game dynamics. Coaches, like Ronald Koeman of the Netherlands, use these breaks to adjust strategies. In several matches, goals were scored soon after play resumed. Teams like Canada, the U.S., and Sweden have benefitted. Yet, the practice has drawn mixed reactions from fans and players.
Fans in stadiums have shown displeasure, with boos heard during the Iraq vs. Norway game in Foxborough, Massachusetts. Breaks occur regardless of the weather, which some believe is unnecessary in climate-controlled venues. Spain coach Luis de la Fuente questioned the need for breaks under certain conditions. Norway coach Staale Solbakken echoed this sentiment, suggesting breaks are only justified in extreme heat.
Besides affecting play, hydration breaks have commercial implications. In the U.S., networks like Fox broadcast commercials during breaks, a rarity in soccer outside halftime. Netherlands captain Virgil van Dijk criticized this approach, noting it impacts the viewing experience. France coach Didier Deschamps remarked on the evolving nature of soccer, highlighting the adaptation required by players and coaches.
FIFA has not confirmed if hydration breaks will continue in future World Cups. The English Football Association indicated such breaks are unlikely for the 2028 European Championship in the U.K. and Ireland.