On February 25, 2023, outside Vanderbilt Medical Center in Nashville, Tennessee, Blaise Taylor responded to police inquiries regarding a date that escalated into a medical crisis. Authorities sought answers about the state of 24-year-old Jade Benning, who had been admitted to the hospital unresponsive. Blaise Taylor described the evening as a date night with Jade.
Initially, the night began with promise for Jade Benning, a professional chef. She planned an intimate evening at her apartment with Blaise Taylor, then a 26-year-old assistant football scout for the Tennessee Titans. Jade intended to cook dinner, followed by painting. However, shortly after taking selfies, she fell ill. Blaise Taylor reported her showing symptoms such as spitting and shaking and immediately consulted his father for advice.
Blaise’s father, a college football coach, was accustomed to handling medical emergencies. Following his brief guidance, Blaise called 911.
Blaise Taylor in his 911 call: “I don’t know what’s happening… She’s got spit coming out of her mouth and she’s shaking.”
Emergency responders discovered Jade lying face down, pulseless. Following the ambulance’s departure with Jade, her close friend Nijaiha Jackson returned to the apartment. Learning of Jade’s condition devastated her.
Nijaiha Jackson: “She has to be OK. I just saw her an hour ago.”
Jade was known for her spirited personality and involvement in cheerleading. Her parents and friends testified she was always a unifier, even reconciling her divorced parents. Moving from Little Rock to Nashville, Jade chased her dream of opening a restaurant.
Dennis Browning, Jade’s father, recounted the details following Jade’s encounter with Blaise.
Bridget Benning Burks, Jade’s mother, noted learning about Blaise when Jade mentioned meeting him soon after her relocation to Nashville. Blaise’s reputation preceded him, recognized for his academic and athletic accomplishments at Arkansas State University. Blaise and his sister Starr established a foundation benefiting children’s education.
In November 2022, Jade informed her mother Bridget about a significant development — a pregnancy with Blaise being the father. Jade planned for the upcoming birth and selected the name Ivy for her daughter. However, during the date night, Jade accused Blaise over the phone of tampering with her drink.
Jade’s friend Nijaiha Jackson received the alarming call, repeating Jade’s accusations to law enforcement and hospital staff.
Nijaiha Jackson: “To have the responsibility of telling my best friend’s mom that something is wrong … needing them to believe me because I knew my friend needed help.”
Neither Blaise nor Jade’s family felt informed about Jade’s critical condition. Initial lab results indicated cocaine in Jade’s system, although her family and friends denied any history of cocaine use. As Jade’s condition deteriorated, her pregnancy compounded the tragedy due to her extended lack of oxygen. Life support was eventually removed on March 6, 2023, Jade’s 25th birthday.
Autopsy results showed extraordinary levels of cocaine toxicity, leading Jade’s mother Bridget to suspect foul play.
In March 2024, Blaise Taylor faced arrest in Utah under homicide charges related to Jade’s demise. Prosecutors argued his intentional actions, culminating in a trial beginning June 2026.
Davidson County Prosecutor Jan Norman alleged Blaise’s plan involved poisoning Jade without realizing the disruption caused by the call to Nijaiha.
During the trial, Nijaiha served as a pivotal witness, recounting Jade’s call.
Nijaiha Jackson in court: Jade accused Blaise of poisoning her drink to harm the baby.
In defense, attorney Letitia Quinones-Hollins questioned the validity of Nijaiha’s testimony, emphasizing the lack of recorded evidence and alternative suspects.
Nijaiha’s unendorsed investigation of the crime scene added complexity, questioning the integrity of collected evidence. Despite uncertainties, prosecutors underlined the unique cocaine toxicity detected.
Apple Dennie, an ex-girlfriend, testified about Blaise’s coercive behavior, adding historical context of his conflict over pregnancy.
Former girlfriend Apple Dennie’s testimony suggested an unscrupulous pattern, including discussions on covertly administering abortion pills.
Defense counsel criticized Apple’s testimony as prejudicial and inadmissible, failing to establish a behavioral pattern.
Medical analysis introduced cocaethylene detection, fueling defense claims on compounded drug interaction explanations and questioned evidence relevance.
Special scrutiny involved the existence of fentanyl identified on Jade’s comforter, complicating the prosecution’s cocaine poison narrative.
Despite alternative defense theories, the prosecution maintained a focus on cocaine as the lethal agent.
After a brief deliberation, the jury delivered guilty verdicts against Blaise for multiple murder counts, reflecting second-degree, premeditated, and felony murder.
Bridget Benning Burks: “Relief. Like a weight lifted that this would never be done to anybody else by him.”
Blaise’s defense team announced intentions to appeal.
For Jade’s family, the outcome represented justice amidst profound personal loss.
