Stephen Miller, a long-time aide to President Donald Trump, faced criticism from his biographer, Jean Guerrero. During an appearance on MS NOW, Guerrero labeled Miller as a ‘sadist.’ The statement followed his appointment as White House chief of staff. Guerrero, author of Hatemonger: Stephen Miller, Donald Trump, and the White Nationalist Agenda, described Miller as someone who enjoys causing pain. She claimed, ‘He despises allies of immigrants more than immigrants themselves.’ These are citizens who advocate for the lesser privileged. Guerrero connected Miller’s ideology to The Camp of the Saints, asserting his views stemmed from this white supremacist novel.
Guerrero predicted Miller would pursue harsh measures against immigrants and Americans supporting them in the coming years. She remarked, ‘Miller is one of the most perilous figures in the White House.’ She accused Trump of amplifying Miller’s inclination towards cruelty. Miller chose not to participate in Guerrero’s biography prior to its 2020 release. Responses from the White House and Guerrero were absent upon HuffPost’s request.
Stephen Miller’s Relationship With ‘The Camp of the Saints’
The Camp of the Saints is a 1973 French novel by Jean Raspail. It describes Indian migrants overtaking a French town. The book stirs white nationalist fears. In 2019, the Southern Poverty Law Center exposed emails revealing Miller’s promotion of the novel to Breitbart News in 2015. Erin Wilson from the Southern Poverty Law Center labeled the book a favorite within extremist circles for its depiction of ‘white genocide.’ The book seemingly influenced Miller’s immigration stance.
During his time with Sen. Jeff Sessions, Miller advised Breitbart to relate the book’s message to Pope Francis’s pro-migrant comments. Consequently, Breitbart published the story, fostering this narrative. Julia Hahn, responsible for the article, later served under Trump’s administration.
The Novel’s Arguments and Its Influence
Chelsea Stieber, a specialist in French literature and culture at Tulane University, analyzed the book. She noted a lack of ‘good guys’ within the novel. The immigrant depiction as a ‘nameless, faceless horde’ is dehumanizing, she said. Pro-immigration Catholics are portrayed as naive. Stieber described the book’s language as overwhelming and promoting a ‘zero-sum view’ on immigration. She doubted the significance of whether Miller read the entire book, emphasizing its reference within far-right circles.
Assessing Miller’s Alleged Sadism
HuffPost consulted researchers about the definition of sadism. They analyzed without diagnosing Miller. Daniel Jones from the University of Nevada considers sadism as part of the ‘dark tetrad’ of personality traits, which also includes narcissism, Machiavellianism, and psychopathy. Jones elucidated that sadists find pleasure in others’ distress.
Psychologist Erin Buckels explained how public actions might suggest sadism. Indicators of sadistic tendencies should be established and policy decisions examined. However, without concrete cues, conclusions remain speculative. Buckels acknowledged, ‘Trends can be observed but intent and rationale behind actions remain uncertain.’
