In 1848, Horace Mann, a prominent education reformer, described public schooling as “the great equalizer of the conditions of men.” Over 175 years later, experts continue to debate the validity of this claim. Some research suggests a child’s family background significantly influences academic achievement more than schools do. Other studies indicate that schools help narrow achievement gaps that would otherwise be much wider.
The Influence of Family Background
A classic study from the 1980s focused on children in Baltimore, examining learning rates among low-income and wealthier kids. It found similar learning rates during the school year, but achievement gaps widened over the summer. Some children engaged in activities like reading with parents, visiting libraries, and attending camps. Others lacked these opportunities.
The extent of summer learning loss remains uncertain. However, initial gaps in reading and math skills between rich and poor children are already significant on the first day of kindergarten. These gaps predominantly arise from factors outside the K-12 education system and persist throughout a student’s school years.
Measuring Educational Investments
As a scholar of education policy, I explore the various elements influencing students’ learning, including teachers and instructional quality. Instead of focusing exclusively on how much students learn at school, my colleagues and I examined what students receive both in and out of school, including school funding, educational support services, and time invested by schools, government programs, and families.
We looked at 77 investment types, such as teachers, tutoring, housing, food, and childcare. We assessed factors without direct costs as well, like the time parents or caregivers spend reading with children. By assigning a monetary value to each factor, we compared what children from diverse backgrounds receive. On average, U.S. children receive approximately $502,000 in investments from birth to age 18.
Investment Disparities
Investment disparities among children are evident early on. By the age of 5, children from the poorest 25% of families receive around $44,000 less in total investments than those from the richest 25%. The gap largely results from housing and childcare costs.
The disparity in total investments diminishes by half, from 24% to 12%, as children enter elementary school. For Black children, the advantage of starting school is even more pronounced. Investment gaps between Black and white children decrease from 20% during early childhood to 7% in kindergarten.
School Investment Impact
Research suggests that increased school spending improves students’ academic performance and long-term outcomes, particularly for low-income families. However, achievement gaps persist during the school years. This outcome partly depends on the use of resources.
Our study reveals that children from the lowest-income families receive 72% more in tutoring and 68% more in special education than those from the highest-income families. Black children receive more than twice as much tutoring as white children.
Role of Tutoring
Tutoring serves as a key tool for catching up. However, a dollar spent on catching up doesn’t equate to a dollar spent on advancing. After the pandemic, schools increasingly relied on tutoring. Studies with randomized tutoring assignments show substantial test-score improvements. Federal Title I funds and pandemic relief money support tutoring in schools serving low-income students.
By 2022-23, over a third of public schools offered high-dosage tutoring, comprising frequent small-group sessions. Schools with more low-income and minority students were more likely to provide it. Nonetheless, for many students, tutoring was already common. From 2014 to 2021, about 17% of school-age children received tutoring, including higher rates among Black and Latino children.
Barriers to Closing Achievement Gaps
Despite increased effort, achievement gaps remain, particularly in high-poverty districts. Federal relief funds aided these districts, but disparities persist compared to pre-pandemic levels.
Beyond Catch-Up Help
Catch-up services alone aren’t enough. Wealthier children gain resources enabling them to get ahead, both in school and extracurricular activities. Our study shows that low-income and minority students often have less experienced teachers than their wealthier, white peers.
Outside school, wealthier families invest more in music lessons, sports, and other activities. By 2024, families in the top 10% spent over 13 times more per child compared to the poorest families on childcare, education, and extracurricular activities.
Conclusion
Public education plays a crucial role in reducing investment gaps between rich and poor children. Yet, equal spending doesn’t translate into equal opportunity. Schools’ extra spending on low-income and minority students primarily addresses pre-existing gaps. To genuinely equalize opportunities, investments in resources that aid advancement are needed. Moreover, gaps forming before kindergarten, concerning housing and childcare, require attention beyond schools alone.
David Blazar, Malen Professor for Urban Education Policy, University of Maryland
This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.
