CBS News New York uncovered records detailing Cornell University’s Title IX investigation of an alleged gang rape involving a fraternity. These records contain interviews with Jane Doe, the men named in her civil lawsuit, and 20 other witnesses. The information is often graphic and disturbing.
One roommate remembered Doe recounting the incident at Chi Phi house while laughing, possibly in shock. Initially, Doe did not label the experience as rape or assault. Another roommate reported that Doe mentioned feeling uncomfortable. A week later, Doe reportedly confronted one of the men, mentioning excessive ketamine use during the encounter.
The transcripts from Cornell’s Title IX investigation, released in January 2025, provide a detailed account but lack the panel’s hearing minutes, reasoning, or final conclusions. In her November interview, Doe stated there was a lack of consent based on excitement and enthusiasm. She expressed her reluctance and discomfort, noting encouragement to consume more substances.
Accused men shared their perspectives during the inquiry. One man claimed Doe’s consent for taking ketamine from her body. Another, Scott Kretzschmar, denied involvement, stating he was present briefly, did not see Doe naked, and did not use drugs. Kretzschmar alleged Doe appeared sober when he checked on her well-being.
The lawsuit implicates seven men with varying allegations, four charged with rape. Kretzschmar’s accusation centers on drug use, which his attorney, Jeremy Saland, disputes. Saland criticized Cornell’s process as biased against the young men.
Cornell defended its Title IX procedure as comprehensive, resulting in multiple sanctions, including expulsions and suspensions. The allegations prompted outrage and scrutiny of Cornell University and police’s case management. Initially, the district attorney chose not to file charges, yet the investigation has now reopened.
CBS News New York remains committed to examining the case thoroughly.