Does a good deed hold less value if the giver enjoys it or gains recognition? Some might think so, but recent research challenges this notion. The study, led by Ohio State University and published in the International Journal of Applied Positive Psychology, shows people appreciate acts of kindness regardless of their selflessness.
Researchers examined how people perceive actions labeled as ‘kind,’ ‘nice,’ and ‘caring.’ Alexia Holovatyk, a licensed clinical psychologist, explained that the findings relieve the pressure to perform ‘pure’ acts of kindness. Many hesitate to act kindly because they worry about ulterior motives, but recipients focus less on these concerns.
The study revealed that ‘kind’ and ‘nice’ are mostly interchangeable, while ‘caring’ requires a higher threshold. Actions that are warm, planned, and unexpected received the most favorable ratings. Jennifer Cheavens, a professor of clinical psychology, began exploring this topic with her seminar students. She referenced a ‘Friends’ episode where characters debate the selflessness of good deeds.
Cheavens consulted developmental psychology professor Laura Wagner for an extensive study involving 14 vignettes covering seven aspects of prosocial behavior. Participants aged 18 to 77 rated scenarios based on how kind, nice, and caring they appeared. They rated higher-cost gestures as nicer and more caring, though not necessarily kinder.
Acts among acquaintances were seen as more caring compared to identical acts among strangers. Cheavens and Wagner suggested ‘caring’ relates to emotion and connection. Holovatyk highlighted that in relationships, the gesture’s impact matters more than its size, suggesting a greater value in presence over selflessness.
Dr. Bonnie King, a counselor with a Ph.D. in counselor education, noted people sometimes worry about appearing self-serving when helping others. However, the study shows others don’t judge good deeds harshly when the giver feels good. Everyday acts like checking in on a friend after a tough week were rated positively for warmth and planning.
Wagner emphasized that feeling good after helping promotes prosocial behavior, motivating cooperation. The researchers believe the insights could assist schools, clinicians, and communities in fostering prosocial actions, avoiding mismatches between concepts like kindness and caring.
Reference: Cheavens, J. S., Wagner, L. et al. (2026). Kind, Nice, and Caring, Oh My! Investigating Differences in How Individuals Interpret Prosocial Language. International Journal of Applied Positive Psychology. https://doi.org/10.1007/s41042-026-00334-5.
