A defamation lawsuit brought by President Trump against The Wall Street Journal (WSJ) has been dismissed. The lawsuit, which sought millions in damages, was related to a WSJ story about Trump’s alleged connection to a birthday book for Jeffrey Epstein. Judge Darrin Gayles of the U.S. District Court in Miami dismissed the case with prejudice on Saturday. This means the lawsuit cannot be filed again.
Judge’s Ruling
Judge Gayles issued a 20-page ruling stating that Trump failed to prove the statements were defamatory with actual malice. According to the judge, the lawsuit appeared to be trying to manufacture faults in WSJ’s reporting. To meet the standard of actual malice for a public figure, it must be shown that statements were made knowing they were false or with disregard for their truthfulness.
Permanent Dismissal
A dismissal with prejudice is both permanent and final. Despite this setback, Trump’s legal team remains resolute. A spokesperson stated that Trump will continue to pursue the lawsuit against WSJ and others involved in the matter. They emphasized their commitment to holding entities accountable for fake news.
Lawsuit Background
The lawsuit stemmed from a WSJ story discussing a letter reportedly bearing Trump’s name in a 2003 album made for Epstein’s 50th birthday. Trump labeled the story as “FAKE” and filed a $20 billion lawsuit against WSJ, its parent company News Corp, CEO, involved reporters, and Rupert Murdoch. The birthday book, later subpoenaed by House lawmakers, contained the letter central to Trump’s claim.
Previous Dismissal
In April, Judge Gayles dismissed the initial lawsuit, highlighting the failure of Trump’s legal team to meet legal requirements. Gayles pointed out the team lacked evidence of actual malice from WSJ. Trump’s legal representatives refiled the lawsuit afterward but faced a similar dismissal.
