Unexpected Lead and Stunning Finale
The Western Michigan Broncos unexpectedly took a 12-7 lead against the Michigan Wolverines at Michigan Stadium in the final seconds. The Wolverines were out of timeouts and appeared to be headed for an upset.
Michigan’s Bryce Underwood threw a Hail Mary into the end zone with the game clock showing 0:00. It seemed that Western Michigan had secured their victory.
Controversial Review Leading to Michigan’s Victory
A review added a second to the clock, allowing Underwood another chance, leading to a victory for Michigan as JJ Buchanan caught the game-winning pass. Fans stormed the field to celebrate.
Many outside Michigan questioned the decision, with the Big Ten citing a different clock during the review process indicating time remained.
Mid-American Conference Files Formal Appeal
The Mid-American Conference disputed the outcome, arguing that the established replay protocol wasn’t followed. They assert the program-feed clock should have been used, which would have negated the additional play.
“After further study and investigation, it is now evident that replay protocol was not properly followed,” the statement said.
They are asking the NCAA FBS Oversight Committee and College Football Playoff to recognize Western Michigan as the winner.
The NCAA Rules and MAC’s Chances
The NCAA rules indicate that video evidence from televised productions should be used for reviews. However, overturning game results is unlikely, especially when big programs like Michigan are involved.
Despite the appeal, the MAC faces an uphill battle. Even if they have valid points, overturning an on-field result is rare.
Big Ten’s Response
The Big Ten stands firm on the decision made by the replay officials, stating no further comments will be made.
Both sides remain entrenched in their positions, suggesting the controversy will remain unresolved.