Bo Naylor, a former catcher for the Cleveland Guardians, testified in a New York court regarding accusations of rigged pitches by Guardians pitchers. Naylor played for the Guardians from 2022 until the recent trade deadline, when he was traded to the Milwaukee Brewers, the eventual World Series champions.
During the trial, Naylor reviewed numerous video clips of pitches thrown by pitchers Emmanuel Clase and Luis Ortiz in 2025. Defense lawyers questioned Naylor about a particular pitch strategy involving a slider thrown to St. Louis Cardinals player Pedro Pages. Naylor explained that catchers and pitchers typically strategize before games on how to exploit hitters’ weaknesses. He emphasized that pitchers, even top ones, cannot always control pitch placement perfectly.
Naylor noted that Emmanuel Clase exhibited solid command over his pitches, especially the fastball, though his offspeed pitches were less consistent. During his testimony, it was also revealed that Naylor frequently saw Clase using a cell phone in the locker room. Prosecutors accuse Clase of breaching Major League Baseball rules by allegedly communicating with gamblers during games.
An indictment claims that bettors profited by $400,000 on pitches thrown by Clase between 2023 and 2025. The allegations suggest that Luis Ortiz joined this scheme in June 2025. In one instance, Clase allegedly coordinated with a bettor during a game using his phone.
Despite these accusations, Clase was renowned as one of the best closers in MLB, boasting a 1.21 ERA in 2024 and a third-place finish in the AL Cy Young Award vote. His ERA increased to 3.80 in 2025 amid the ongoing investigation. Ortiz had a lifetime ERA of 4.36, achieving a 3.32 ERA in his best season in 2024.
Clase, who formerly signed a five-year contract worth $20 million in 2022, had completed a notable rookie year. In contrast, Luis Ortiz was earning the league’s veteran minimum salary at the time, as he had not yet reached arbitration eligibility.
