Alaska’s race for its sole U.S. House seat initially appears straightforward. Republican Representative Nick Begich III leads with 47.71% against independent Bill Hill’s 41.72%, based on unofficial results from the Alaska Division of Elections. Democrat Eric Hafner and Libertarian James C. McDermott trail with 7.78% and 2.63%, respectively. Write-ins account for 430 votes. However, first-round choices alone do not determine the outcome; ranked-choice voting plays a crucial role.
According to an analysis by Newsweek, run through tabulation software, Begich secured 51.5%, and Hill 48.49% in the final round. These figures come from estimated calculations, with ballots still being counted, as the Associated Press has not declared an official result. Official tabulation by the Alaska Division of Elections is set for November 18, with certification by November 25.
How Ranked-Choice Voting Works
Alaska voters rank up to four candidates. If no candidate garners a majority in initial tallies, the candidate with the fewest votes gets eliminated, and their votes transfer to the next preferred candidate. This process continues until one candidate achieves a majority.
The Division of Elections provides a cast vote record, capturing all machine-read rankings but excluding hand-counted ballots. Newsweek processed this data using RCTab software, adhering to state rules on write-ins, overvotes, and skipped rankings.
Round-by-Round Analysis
The record comprises 282,698 ballots, with 2,177 ballots ranking no candidate. Inactive ballots from the first round include 194 overvotes and 250 skipped rankings. Newsweek’s initial round showed Begich with 47.7%, Hill with 41.71%, Hafner with 7.78%, and McDermott with 2.65% of the counted votes.
Throughout the elimination process, write-ins, McDermott, and Hafner dropped from the race in sequence. Hill gained support from eliminated candidates’ ballots, but not enough to overtake Begich’s lead.
In the final comparison, Begich holds a narrow lead over Hill with 266,472 active ballots. Some 14,049 have become inactive during the process.
Remaining Uncertainties
Discrepancies between Newsweek’s output and the Division’s official cast vote record remain. The latter excludes ballots accounted for by hand, leaving a 191-vote gap unexplained. The count continues, with the AP estimating 97% of votes tallied, suggesting thousands of ballots pending.
For Hill to surpass Begich, remaining unscanned ballots, including overseas votes accepted until November 18, must largely favor him. The Division’s upcoming official ranking will shed more light on these dynamics.
