A judge in Alaska decided that a request from Democratic U.S. Senate candidate Mary Peltola’s campaign was unreasonable. The campaign sought a list of absentee voters whose ballots were rejected. This request came amid the ongoing count of ballots from last week’s election, where Peltola and Republican Senator Dan Sullivan are major contenders. Alaska’s Senate race is the only one in the country yet undecided.
The state allows ballots to be received up to 15 days post-election from overseas voters, with November 18 set as the deadline. This date also serves as the target for the Division of Elections to conduct ranked vote tabulations if no candidate receives over 50% of the first-choice votes.
Peltola’s campaign filed a lawsuit on the previous Friday, seeking reasons for the rejection of absentee ballots. Their aim was to verify that all eligible voters had their votes counted. However, state attorneys argued that the release of such information would breach voter privacy. They also stated that generating this list from the voter database would be classified as an electronic product or service, which legally should not take precedence over the agency’s primary functions.
Superior Court Judge Thomas Matthews, in his written statement, acknowledged that records could theoretically be redacted to allow their release. However, he emphasized that the division is not mandated to provide this information as requested by the campaign. He noted that the records in question cannot be produced or redacted feasibly at present.
Matthews remarked that the division faces pressing deadlines and has staff working extensive hours to carry out its essential duty of managing elections. He commented that the campaign’s timing in making this request was very poorly chosen.
The state Department of Law, which stood for the Division of Elections, expressed satisfaction with Matthews’ ruling. Meanwhile, Abha Khanna, representing Peltola’s campaign, stressed that their aim was not to interfere with the ballot counting process. She claimed that the absentee ballot review was proceeding smoothly.
Khanna argued that the information being sought is publicly accessible and aligns with what campaign observers can view during absentee review board meetings. The campaign wanted centralized access to this data.
State attorneys contended that the division’s reports on ballots under review are not public records. They are considered temporary working documents that contain confidential information not intended for record-keeping.
Michaela Thompson, in charge of absentee ballot reviews, stated that the report version seen by campaign observers contains less confidential data but includes home addresses, which many voters wish to keep private. Observers sign confidentiality agreements to prevent them from copying or recording this information.
She noted that the division’s outdated database couldn’t produce reports without these confidential addresses. To obtain such a tailored report, collaboration with a vendor would be necessary.
