The 2026 college football season witnessed a pivotal victory when the BYU Cougars defeated the Notre Dame Fighting Irish in Provo. This win significantly boosted BYU’s credentials and highlighted the Big 12 Conference’s national relevance. BYU quickly emerged as a contender for the College Football Playoff, positioning themselves as a top-tier team.
However, BYU faced a setback when they unexpectedly lost to UCF in Florida. This diminished some anticipation for their matchup against the Utah Utes on November 7. But the quality of this rivalry game, commonly known as the “Holy War,” was undeniable. Utah emerged victorious, winning 28-20 in a closely contested battle, further cementing the Big 12’s competitive stature.
Utah’s triumph led them to climb to No. 2 in the latest AP Top 25 Poll, trailing only the Georgia Bulldogs. With a 9-0 record in the Power 4 conference, including significant victories over top-15 ranked Houston Cougars and BYU, Utah has become a strong candidate for a playoff spot. They are now favorites to win the Big 12 Conference and potentially secure a first-round playoff bye.
“Are they a great football team? I don’t think we know the answer to that,” senior analyst Heather Didich commented on Utah’s playoff aspirations on ESPN’s “Get Up” show.
Despite Utah’s impressive performance, ESPN analyst Heather Didich expressed skepticism over Utah’s championship potential. She noted that their ascension in rankings was partly due to other teams’ losses and questioned the team’s readiness to clinch a national title, citing their struggle against Colorado.
Furthermore, Didich highlighted that Utah’s victory over BYU benefited from Bear Bachmeier’s errors. She voiced concerns about Utah’s capability to compete against teams like Georgia. Paul Finebaum shared a more assertive stance, openly stating Utah’s inability to win the national championship.
The critical perspective towards Utah does not entirely reflect their performance. Comparisons with Georgia reveal biases, as Georgia lost to Auburn, a team with a mixed season record. Utah, conversely, maintained an undefeated season within their schedule. ESPN’s SP+ ranking system, based on efficiency metrics, places Utah close to other SEC powerhouses like Alabama, underscoring their potential as serious contenders.
It remains uncertain if Utah will capture the national title. Factors such as playoff dynamics, potential injuries, and unpredictable game outcomes add complexity to their path. However, the media portrayal of Utah’s capabilities would likely shift if they had a more favored team brand.
