Family members of Dan J. Sullivan, also known as “Decoy Dan,” have gone on lockdown as the search continues for the missing US Senate candidate from Alaska. Sullivan disappeared shortly before the midterm elections on Nov. 3. He shares a name with the incumbent Republican US senator from Alaska, Daniel S. Sullivan. Dan J. Sullivan was last seen on Oct. 26 at the Anchorage airport, reportedly leaving town.
Sources in Petersburg, where Sullivan and his wife Karen Dillman reside, suggest he left before the elections to Colorado, where many of his in-laws live. Sullivan ran a campaign in the 2026 Alaska US Senate election, which many consider a spoiler effort against Daniel S. Sullivan’s Republican campaign.
A relative in Durango told The Post that she had not heard from Sullivan recently. A young woman at the location, displaying a Southern Poverty Law Center sticker, described herself as a relative staying there.
Sullivan’s independent run is seen as potentially orchestrated by Democrat candidate Mary Peltola’s campaign, a claim both parties deny. Legal experts suggest possible legal consequences for Sullivan, including charges of conspiracy to confuse voters or wire fraud. Former federal prosecutor Jim Trusty stated that if Sullivan remains uncontacted by the FBI, he could avoid false statement charges.
Mary Peltola’s campaign has denied involvement in Sullivan’s candidacy. Sullivan’s name on the ballot attracted 4,600 votes. His supporters and family, including his son Noah Sullivan, who works for Democratic Rep. Marie Gluesenkamp Perez, generally lean liberal.
Speculation surrounds Sullivan’s disappearance, with some suggesting he and Dillman, a retired lichen expert, might have gone off-grid. A neighbor mentioned their likelihood of camping in the Colorado woods due to their outdoorsy lifestyle.
Mary Peltola declared victory in the Senate race, leading Dan S. Sullivan with 49.8% to his 46%. Decoy Dan received about 1.7% of the votes. Alaska’s ranked-choice voting system could lead to a runoff if no candidate reaches 50%.
Attorney and former FEC member Hans Spakovsky criticized Sullivan’s disappearance as evidence of a sham candidacy intended to mislead voters. President Donald Trump accused Sullivan of a “criminal act,” while federal authorities are gathering statements from Sullivan’s donors, potentially to build a wire fraud case if donors believed they supported the incumbent.
Questions revolve around any potential quid pro quo between Sullivan and Peltola’s campaign. Trusty pondered whether communication showed Sullivan’s intent to confuse voters supporting the incumbent.
Sullivan hasn’t been charged officially, though concerns persist about potential long-term ramifications if “Decoy Dan” goes unpunished. Spakovsky noted that federal authorities might be building a civil case against Peltola.
Petersburg residents found Sullivan and Dillman’s sudden disappearance unusual, with the FBI now having largely left town. Dillman reportedly contributed to Peltola’s campaign while acting as her husband’s treasurer.
Spakovsky remarked on the irony if the DOJ pursued Sullivan using similar fraud accusations as those leveled against President Trump post-2020 elections.
