Review of ‘Downstate’ at the Booth Theatre

Review of ‘Downstate’ at the Booth Theatre

The production of Downstate at the Booth Theatre, located at 222 West 45th Street, runs for two hours and 30 minutes with one intermission. The initial atmosphere is almost soothing, as familiar sights like a couch, a kitchen, and a dining table set the stage before the show begins. However, a peculiar and unsettling video plays in the corner—a TV set showing an episode of ‘The Smurfs’. The presence of these tiny, innocent blue characters being pursued by the evil Gargamel sets a strange tone.

Playwright Bruce Norris uses this seemingly random video as a prelude, highlighting how audiences might view his main characters: convicted sex offenders and pedophiles. This theme is not typical for Broadway, and many may recoil at the premise. The play, which opened on Sunday evening, previously sparked controversy during its off-Broadway run at Playwrights Horizons four years ago. Despite protests from those who hadn’t seen it, Downstate has maintained its reputation for being daring and unsettling.

Set in a modest apartment in Illinois, referred to as “downstate,” the play centers around four men living together after serving time for their crimes. The living conditions are reminiscent of a neglected college dorm. Their offenses vary, and they are classified from low to high risk. Unlike most theatrical works, Norris doesn’t push the audience to feel any specific way about these characters. Instead, reactions from viewers are diverse, with spontaneous applause for arguments presented on both sides of the issue.

K. Todd Freeman portrays Dee, a realist and spokesperson for the group. Alongside Fred, an elderly character confined to a motor scooter and played by Francis Guinan, they draw mixed feelings. While their demeanor might suggest warmth, their past actions tell another story. Dee’s humor complicates the viewer’s perception, allowing laughter despite the gravity of his offenses.

The group includes Gio, portrayed by Al’Jaleel McGhee, the lone level one offender who committed his crime under circumstances that seem less severe. Gio’s character exudes charisma, fueling dreams of entrepreneurship despite unlikely prospects. Felix, the quietest among them, spends his time in prayer, further adding to the apartment’s tense atmosphere.

The parole officer, Ivy—played by Liza Colón-Zayas—initially appears severe but reveals a levelheadedness during a scene with Felix. The narrative pivots when a character named Andy, played by Thomas Sadoski, visits to confront Fred about past trauma. The encounter is complex and emotionally charged, showcasing devastating performances.

The seasoned actors Guinan and Freeman bring experience to their roles, which is essential given their characters’ backgrounds. In the current theater scene, dominated by celebrity appearances, some performances lack attentiveness. However, Freeman and Guinan deliver intense, thoughtful portrayals.

Directed by Joe Mantello, fresh from his work on Death of a Salesman, each scene in Downstate is taut and purposeful. The production is intense, igniting strong reactions and sparking discussion. This play challenges norms with its unflinching narrative and engaging performances, focusing on difficult subjects that often go unaddressed in mainstream theater.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *