Over 285,000 Canadians have signed a petition calling for the expulsion of US Ambassador to Canada, Pete Hoekstra. The petition accuses him of political interference and undermining Canadian sovereignty. It closed on November 18 and urged Prime Minister Mark Carney’s government to declare Hoekstra persona non grata. The accusations focus on Hoekstra’s comments about Canada becoming the 51st state of the US and his alleged connections with Alberta separatists.
Elizabeth May, a former Green Party leader, sponsored the petition. She described Hoekstra as unfit for his diplomatic role and suggested he might be deliberately harming relations between the US and Canada. Despite sponsoring the petition, May stated that it does not imply her support for the demand to expel Hoekstra.
Role of MPs in Petition Sponsorship
In Canada, MPs act as intermediaries for petitioners and can sponsor petitions without endorsing the contents. Parliamentary rules also prevent MPs from debating a petition’s merits when presenting it in the House of Commons. May explained her role as giving Canadians a parliamentary voice, independent of her personal position.
She noted that the large number of signatures reflects a significant message from Canadians. May contrasted Hoekstra’s controversial role with David Wilkins, a former ambassador who was well-regarded despite working under an unpopular US administration.
Canadian Government’s Stance
Prime Minister Mark Carney has previously rejected calls to remove Hoekstra, emphasizing the need to maintain diplomatic relations with Washington despite tensions over Trump’s policies. Carney highlighted the importance of trade and security ties between the countries.
Carney, when asked about the 51st state remarks, stated that working with the current US administration is essential. He stressed the importance of not reacting to every provocative statement.
Petition Allegations and Breakdown of Support
The petition originated in July by Calgary resident Leanne Walker. It accuses Hoekstra of labeling Canada’s federal election as anti-American and using Trump’s 51st-state comments as a term of endearment. It also questions alleged meetings between Alberta separatist leaders and US State Department officials.
While Hoekstra denied knowledge of these meetings, the campaign attracted substantial support from Ontario, British Columbia, and Alberta. Hoekstra dismissed the demands for his removal, emphasizing his support from the US President and defending his social media activities.
Despite the petition’s signatures, it cannot force Hoekstra’s removal. Under Canadian rules, May can present it formally to the House of Commons, requiring a government response within 45 days.
Persona Non Grata Procedures
Canada can declare an envoy persona non grata under the Vienna Convention. This would require Washington to recall Hoekstra or stop his diplomatic duties. Canada has previously expelled diplomats suspected of interference, as seen with Chinese and Indian diplomats.
However, expelling Hoekstra could spark a diplomatic standoff amid trade negotiations with Washington. Carney has advised against responding to all provocative statements from the Trump administration.
