Jewish Doctor Secures Exemption from Union Membership Due to Religious Beliefs

Jewish Doctor Secures Exemption from Union Membership Due to Religious Beliefs

A Jewish doctor, Dr. Jacob Agronin, has received an exemption from union membership and fees after contesting a mandate requiring financial support for a union which he argued conflicted with his religious beliefs. As a physician at Temple University Hospital in Philadelphia, Dr. Agronin won this exemption with the help of America First Legal (AFL).

AFL intervened by bringing the case to the Committee of Interns and Residents (CIR), part of the Service Employees International Union (SEIU) Local 1957. They demanded that Dr. Agronin be exempted from union membership and fees based on the union’s positions on Israel. These positions reportedly include support for the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) movement and accusations against Israel of apartheid and genocide.

The CIR’s collective bargaining agreement with Temple University Hospital required employees to either join the union or pay agency fees. According to AFL, Dr. Agronin objected specifically because the union’s stance on Israel contradicted his religious beliefs.

A Temple University Hospital physician was granted a religious exemption from union membership and fees. (Jessica Kourkounis/Reuters)

Megan Redshaw, AFL’s counsel, explained to Fox News Digital that Dr. Agronin was not opposing the union’s political speech per se. Instead, his religious objections were due to the impact these viewpoints have in the workplace, making this a Title VII issue with implications for religious accommodation.

Dr. Agronin was concerned that any financial backing, even if excluding political activities, would infringe on his beliefs. Consequently, the union confirmed in a letter dated October 9 that it had agreed to an accommodation, ensuring that Dr. Agronin remained outside the union membership and fee structures. His paycheck will not reflect any deductions linked to the union.

CIR represents over 40,000 resident physicians and fellows committed to enhancing residency training, patient care, and healthcare access. Despite this mission, Redshaw criticized the union for promoting political and ideological causes without members’ explicit consent.

In May 2024, CIR adopted resolutions such as “Housestaff for Human Rights” and “Housestaff Against Apartheid.” These resolutions demanded no candidate endorsements for those accepting donations from the Israel lobby or supporting alleged genocide and apartheid. The resolutions also called for ending military aid to Israel and supporting the BDS movement.

Following events in October 2023, CIR issued a statement expressing dismay at violence in Israel and Palestine. The union urged U.S. leaders to restore essentials in Gaza, ensure hostage releases, and advocate for ceasefire initiatives.

In May 2026, Dr. Agronin referenced CIR’s earlier statements during his testimony to the House Education and Workforce Committee’s Subcommittee. He acknowledged aspects of their response that respected casualties on both sides but critiqued others, such as not naming Hamas and glossing over antisemitism issues.

Redshaw suggested that other physicians with similar religious objections might qualify for full exemptions from union participation. She pointed out that depending on the state, members could entirely withdraw from the union rather than directing fees toward causes chosen by the union.

Temple University Hospital and CIR have not yet responded to requests for comment on this issue.

Rachel Wolf contributed to this report as a media and culture reporter.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *