After weeks of community protests and a looming lawsuit, the Evanston/Skokie School District 65 Board has decided to move forward with plans to close Dewey and Lincolnwood elementary schools by the end of the 2026-27 school year. This decision was reached despite a budget proposal fraught with significant errors. On Nov. 16, financial auditors disclosed a multi-million dollar budget mistake, marking the third such error. They noted that the expected property tax revenue for the district will be approximately $7.3 million less per year than projected. This shortfall results in even less revenue for the district, which had planned to cut $20 million from its 2028 budget.
Earlier, the budget proposal had a $17 million mistake that was later found to be a $27 million error. This misjudgment in expected building upkeep costs over the next five years was an overcount, indicating the district had underestimated available funds. Amid these financial miscalculations, Board members were divided. By a 4-3 vote, members Pat Anderson, Mya Wilkins, Andrew Wymer, and Sergio Hernandez supported the school closures. Board President Nichole Pinkard, Vice President Chris Van Nostrand, and member Maria Opdycke voted against the measure.
The packed meeting at the Joseph E. Hill Early Childhood Center in Evanston saw heated discussions. President Pinkard clarified that the vote wasn’t a decision to close Dewey and Lincolnwood but to begin the public hearing process required by Illinois law before considering school closures. Pinkard emphasized the distinction to the worried families, ensuring the vote was only an initial step. Three public hearings for each school will follow, allowing community members to express their views. The Board will hold a final vote after these hearings, which are expected to start by the end of 2026.
The decision did not extend to other elements of the budget proposal, such as staff reductions, operational changes, and the closure of Head Start programs in 2029. These items will be addressed at a future meeting. Last week, the district reversed its plan to end the childcare program after reaching an agreement with the Evanston Association of Childcare Professionals, averting the closure of the program supporting 44 paraprofessional workers.
Pinkard urged the Board to ask questions whenever necessary to fully understand the proposal and its outcomes. Some Board members stressed the dire financial situation, necessitating an urgent, significant response; others advocated for a cautious approach. Citing historical decisions, Vice President Van Nostrand warned against making politically expedient choices disguised as progress.
Board member Opdycke expressed skepticism about validating the proposed cuts, while Dewey parent Alexandra Miller criticized the found $27 million financial error. Parental reactions were mixed, with some like Ena Kumar lamenting possible future sacrifices the community would need to make, potentially driving families away. Alexandra Miller voiced concerns that the new error could damage public trust and influence future referendum votes necessary for district improvements.
Board members have discussed a tentative capital referendum campaign for the 2028 election to support facility upgrades and renovations, though it should not be relied upon solely for financial recovery. District 65 parent William Banks likened the decision to a ‘self-inflicted wound,’ underscoring the contentious nature of the Board’s choice.
