Craig Carton Questions NCAA’s Role
Craig Carton expressed outrage at the NCAA following their admission of significant protocol failures in the Michigan versus Western Michigan controversy. The sportscaster questioned the governing body’s existence if it lacks authority to reverse disputed calls.
Virginia Tech vs. Pittsburgh Thriller
Virginia Tech Hokies faced a dramatic defeat against Pittsburgh, ending their first game of the season with a tight score of 35-33. Early dominance by the Hokies was eclipsed by Pittsburgh’s comeback. Both teams fiercely competed until the Hokies missed a potential game-winning field goal, narrowly wide to the left.
“By ‘wide to the left,’ I’m not entirely sure.” – Craig Carton
The ball seemed to barely miss the left upright. Fans believed Virginia Tech kicker John Love had made it, as did Love himself. Yet, referees ruled differently, leaving fans frustrated.
Debates Over Field Goal’s Validity
Various angles of the kick surfaced online. Some supported Virginia Tech’s belief in the goal’s success, evidenced by fan reactions. Others favored the referee’s call, showing the kick potentially missed wide left. Such differing perspectives fueled debate over the referees’ decision.
The NCAA rulebook adds further complexity by restricting reviews for kicks crossing above the uprights. This rule prevented any chance of overturning the play.
For those looking up the rule:
- Field goal attempts are reviewed only if the ball is below or above the crossbar, or inside or outside the uprights when lower than their top.
- Kicks crossing above uprights are not subject to review.
NCAA regulations contrast with NFL’s detailed rulebook, which specifies conditions for successful field goals.
“The professional league’s rules differ slightly.” – Context from NCAA and NFL regulations
The NCAA does not mention balls going above uprights, only “between” them, leaving ambiguity in interpretation.