The release of the first College Football Playoff rankings on Tuesday night has sparked debate among college football fans. Alabama’s placement at No. 5, despite a recent loss to Tennessee, has raised eyebrows. Tennessee is ranked No. 13, even though they defeated Alabama by 16 points just two weeks ago.
On Wednesday, The Craig Carton Show expressed strong opinions on the matter. Carton questioned the committee’s decision, noting, “How is Alabama ranked fifth when Tennessee is ranked 13th? Inquiring minds want to know.” He highlighted that both teams have two losses, suggesting that Tennessee should be ranked higher due to their head-to-head victory.
The discussion highlighted frustrations with the ranking process, which often seems to favor teams like Alabama, regardless of their recent performances. Carton argued that head-to-head matchups should be a primary factor in rankings, as they provide direct evidence of a team’s capabilities. “Tennessee dominated Alabama,” he stated, emphasizing the on-field result.
Despite Alabama’s losses, the committee continues to rank the Crimson Tide near the top. Carton noted, “Here we are, like we always are, currying favor with the Crimson Tide,” and expressed skepticism about their high ranking.
Carton also addressed the perception of Alabama’s prominence in college football. He concluded, “I’m not saying that Tennessee got unfairly treated, but Alabama’s ranking is affecting other teams.” He firmly believes that Alabama should not be ranked No. 5 and that they will not win the national title this year.
