Paula Turley, now 79, recounted her last conversation with her friend Karen Snider, which took place on the morning of November 12, 1966. They spoke about feeding their baby daughters and Turley’s upcoming birthday. Turley testified in court that she and Snider talked every morning.
That night, Snider, then 18, was found stabbed to death in her Calumet City home. Decades later, Turley’s former husband, James Barbier, was arrested in Missouri in 2024. He faces charges of first-degree murder in Snider’s death after the case went cold. His trial commenced this week.
Barbier had worked alongside Snider’s husband at the Indiana Harbor Belt Railroad. The two families were close, Turley mentioned during her testimony. Both Turley and Snider gave birth to daughters in August 1966, and Turley described Snider as her best friend.
Turley recounted that her family visited her at their home in Gary, Indiana, on the evening of the murder. While in the kitchen, she noticed Barbier’s return around dusk, mainly because she heard the washing machine running in the basement. This stood out as unusual since Barbier seldom did laundry. She encountered him only when he emerged upstairs, dressed in clean clothes, but with cuts on his face.
He was in clean clothes then. He had cuts on his face.– Paula Turley
Cook County Chief Medical Examiner Ponni Arunkumar provided detailed testimony about Snider’s injuries. She was stabbed more than 120 times, including 18 times in the neck. Arunkumar explained that several neck wounds damaged her larynx, jugular vein, and carotid artery, even reaching her spine. Other injuries to the abdomen affected her heart, aorta, and liver. Snider also had defensive wounds on her hands.
Turley revealed that Barbier served as a pallbearer at Snider’s funeral, where his face remained bandaged. After Snider’s death, Barbier relocated to Missouri, followed by a divorce a year later, leaving Turley without financial support.
During the trial, Assistant Public Defender Tom Justic questioned Turley’s recollection of the events from 1966, highlighting what he described as inconsistencies in her testimony over the years. Justic emphasized that Turley previously stated she saw Barbier return home, though she now claimed otherwise. She had also varied in her descriptions of Barbier’s facial injuries.
Retired Chicago police Capt. John Collins, now 91, testified about his role in processing the crime scene in 1966. He noted that evidence technicians did not wear gloves then and were unfamiliar with DNA. All the crime scene photos from that time were captured in black and white.
The trial continues at the Markham Courthouse.
