Rethinking Temporary Protected Status for Haitians

Rethinking Temporary Protected Status for Haitians

On August 20, the United States sent over 160 individuals back to Haiti. This marked the first deportation flight since the government ended temporary protected status (TPS) for about 350,000 Haitians. The plane included a number of former TPS holders and landed in Cap-Haïtien instead of Port-au-Prince due to security concerns at the latter’s airport, impacting U.S. commercial flights.

TPS allows qualifying foreign nationals to live and work in the U.S. when their home countries are deemed unsafe for return. Haiti’s 2010 earthquake, which resulted in over 220,000 deaths and displaced 1.5 million people, initially justified TPS designation. For 15 years, U.S. administrations extended Haiti’s designation. However, a Supreme Court decision in June resulted in Haitians losing their TPS protection.

Both advocates and opponents of TPS use its 15-year span to support their views, but a crucial consideration is often missed: how to respond when a temporary disaster becomes chronic.

My parents emigrated from Haiti to the U.S. during the 1980s. This was not driven by a natural disaster but reflects a broader narrative where migration often predates catastrophic events. Through my work in developing network infrastructures that connect people and economies, I have learned about resilience and systems’ ability to adapt despite failures. A well-structured network can survive losing a link. Yet, without adequate investment, recovery remains partial, increasing system vulnerability.

Data from the Internal Displacement Monitoring Center shows that between 2008 and 2023, approximately 2.9 million internal displacements were due to 44 natural disasters in Haiti, with a population of around 10 million. Frequent shocks have hindered recovery efforts. Additionally, Haitian governments have struggled with instability, elite dominance, and chronic underinvestment. Particularly in rural areas, fewer than 10% of people have electricity, which has exaggerated urban migration.

Observed globally, climate and natural disasters exacerbate already stressed systems. Instead of relying solely on TPS renewals or terminations influenced by current assessments, Congress should devise a process recognizing when emergencies extend into prolonged national crises.

I recommend a two-phase national stability review initiated by the Departments of Homeland Security and State once a country’s TPS has persisted for 10 years. This process would assess whether the situation has become chronic, evaluating the consistency and severity of conditions, the impact of climate factors, and the feasibility of safe returns within a specific period.

Not all long-term crises would prompt designation, but where chronic conditions exist, a second-stage individual assessment would determine eligibility for permanent residence based on strong U.S. ties, with appropriate screenings.

While Congress has provided relief for certain groups and proposed acts like the American Dream and Promise Act, a national stability review would better address if TPS remains viable for sustained crises. It wouldn’t offer automatic residency but would reconsider prolonged TPS renewals.

Extending temporary protection for 15 years highlights political inertia and questions the term ‘temporary’ for crises lasting so long. A nation unable to safely welcome planes to its capital signals systemic failure. Congress must distinguish between acute and structural issues to establish a nuanced path for individuals affected by chronic conditions.

Alex-Handrah Aimé serves as vice president of Network Investments at Meta, focusing on infrastructure linking data centers. Born in Port-au-Prince, Haiti, she is a PD Soros Fellow and a 2026 Public Voices Fellow with the OpEd Project.

Copyright 2026 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *