In 2018, the U.S. Supreme Court delivered a significant decision in Janus v. AFSCME, firmly stating that public-sector employees cannot be obligated to pay union dues as a job requirement. Yet, eight years later, the Court’s commitment to upholding this principle remains uncertain.
Recent laws enacted in Oregon and New York are bringing this issue back to the forefront. While both states assert these laws aim to prevent fraudulent impersonations of labor unions, their true focus targets organizations like the Freedom Foundation. This watchdog group helps government employees understand their rights to opt-out of union membership and dues.
Oregon’s law, established last year, aims to prevent false impersonations of union representatives, imposing penalties of $6,250 per violation. The Freedom Foundation legally challenged this law, contending that its communication practices comply and that the law suppresses constitutionally protected speech. After facing a setback in a federal district court, the organization has taken the case to the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals.
New York’s similar measure, Civil Service Law Section 216, was introduced in the spring. It empowers Attorney General Letitia James to take action if she believes prohibited communications have occurred or are imminent. Offenders face fines up to $1,000 per incident. In response, the Freedom Foundation filed a lawsuit against New York in late September.
The crux of these legal battles is not only about prosecution outcomes but the suppressive effect on free speech. Despite lacking proof that the Freedom Foundation misled anyone, these laws force the organization to weigh the risks of potential accusations of “material omission” or “deception” in their communications. This precursory chilling of speech discourages free expression by escalating the perceived risk of speaking out.
Since Janus, unions and their supporters have devised strategies to hinder the opt-out process. The Freedom Foundation has aided numerous workers in these disputes, yet the Supreme Court has declined to involve itself in post-Janus cases, allowing these matters to fester unchecked.
The laws in Oregon and New York signify further escalation in the struggle over labor rights. They not only obstruct employees from exercising their rights but also threaten to withhold crucial information necessary for making informed decisions.
The Janus case—and the First Amendment—do not typically cover fraud, as states already possess mechanisms to address genuine fraud. However, leveraging potential fraud allegations to stifle opposing voices is a misuse of power.
These cases impact more than just the Freedom Foundation; they challenge broader free speech rights. Success in federal court could carve a clearer path for the Supreme Court to definitively reinforce the principles outlined in Janus and affirm that constitutional rights cannot be burdened by strategic legislative maneuvers.
Jeff Rhodes serves as the vice president of news and information at the Freedom Foundation.
© 2026 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. This material is prohibited from being published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
