For years, residents of the 135 houses in Porter Beach have pushed for a sanitary sewer to replace outdated septic systems that risk contaminating Lake Michigan. The town of Porter agrees with the need for this upgrade to service Porter Beach and potential development sites north of U.S. 20.
A significant opportunity for development lies at the former Johnson Inn site, eyed by Valparaiso businessman Chuck Williams. However, the lack of a sanitary sewer hinders progress. A new Indiana state rule, effective January 1, 2027, increases urgency by banning repairs on existing septic systems near Lake Michigan. This leaves residents in a dilemma if systems fail post-2027.
Rob Albrecht-Mallinger, a Porter Beach resident involved in local governance, supports service enhancements. He understands the state’s push for environmentally friendly solutions but criticizes the new rule for its lack of preparation time. Under new restrictions, Porter County can’t permit repairs for failing systems after the deadline.
On October 27, the Porter Town Council requested the state delay these regulations. The resolution highlighted financial strains, supply chain delays, and a shortage of specialists as barriers to meeting the 2027 timeline. The unique geography of the area adds to the difficulty.
Restricting permit issuance affects the health and welfare of residents, the resolution asserts.
Councilwoman Laura Madigan emphasized the priority of transitioning to sewer systems and aims for completion by 2030 with funding support. Michael Barry, Porter’s development director and building superintendent, noted demands for sewers since 1989. He explained that Porter Beach originally served as seasonal cabins, complicating updates.
Optimism grows for funding sewer lines. Once the Johnson Inn property clears probate, developer Chuck Williams plans to purchase it. Other lakeside communities face similar issues. Beverly Shores, ahead of the curve, secured an EPA grant for engineering studies. Barry expresses a desire for similar support for Porter.
David Phelps, Beverly Shores Town Council president, reported initial evaluations of sewer feasibility for 500 homes, considering a connection to Michigan City’s system. Funding remains a challenge due to limited local tax revenue.
