‘Elsinore’ brings Andrew Scott to the forefront, portraying Scottish actor Ian Charleson. Set in London, 1989, the film focuses on Charleson’s struggles with fame and illness. Known for his role in ‘Chariots of Fire,’ Charleson is haunted by the film’s iconic theme, even when catching a cab. His bigger battle, however, is living with AIDS during a period when the disease was deemed a death sentence.
A career breakthrough emerges when Daniel Day-Lewis exits ‘Hamlet’ at the National Theatre, offering Charleson a chance to play the celebrated Danish prince. Despite medical warnings from Dr. Margaret Johnson, portrayed by Olivia Colman, Charleson takes on the role. Dr. Johnson, an HIV treatment pioneer, warns of the toll on his health. Meanwhile, Derek Jarman, the pioneering queer director, challenges Charleson on his public silence about his sexuality. David Dawson plays Jarman, adding a layer of critique and support.
Scott, openly gay himself, delivers an emotive performance, echoing his previous subtle roles. His task here is layered, involving vibrant Shakespearean readings and a realistic portrayal of health decline. Yet, director Simon Stone and writer Stephen Beresford frequently reduce the film to montage, inadequately exploring the intertwining of Charleson’s artistry and illness.
‘Elsinore’ honors an actor’s swan song, capturing a poignant narrative of a life in art amid inevitable decline.
Contrasting ‘Elsinore,’ ‘I Play Rocky’ takes an uplifting tone. Directed by Peter Farrelly, it highlights Sylvester Stallone’s ascent in Hollywood. Anthony Ippolito mirrors Stallone’s persona, depicting young Stallone’s precarious life in New York. Faced with eviction and financial struggles, Stallone’s life choices—adopting a dog and acting in a softcore film—mark his determination.
The film showcases Stallone’s journey post-writing the ‘Rocky’ screenplay, inspired by the 1975 Ali-Wepner fight. A crucial plot point is Stallone’s condition to star in his own script, amidst corporate negotiations expertly navigated by P.J. Byrne and Toby Kebbell as producers. Tracy Letts adds humor as the persistent executive eyeing bigger stars.
While ‘Rocky’ finds success, ‘I Play Rocky’ frames the narrative with preordained triumphs. Yet, in Ippolito, the film finds a true embodiment of its subject, capturing the essence beyond the screenplay’s limitations.
In summation, ‘Elsinore’ crafts a tragic farewell in its reflection on Ian Charleson, while ‘I Play Rocky’ spins a tale of triumph with Stallone at its heart.
