Steve Balich, a long-serving Will County Board member, initially led by 194 votes on Election Night. However, this lead vanished after the mail-in and provisional ballots were counted. As of Tuesday, Balich, from Homer Glen, trails Lockport Democrat Sheri Boniecki-Cooling by 12 votes. Balich announced that he will request a recount.
Updated results on the county clerk’s website show Boniecki-Cooling with 9,654 votes and Balich with 9,642. These are provisional totals. The results will become official when the canvass is completed by November 24.
Four candidates competed for two four-year terms to represent District 4 on the Will County Board. This district covers Homer Glen, Mokena, Lockport, and Tinley Park. Boniecki-Cooling, who founded the Homer Township Democratic Organization, expressed her excitement upon seeing the updated numbers. “This is thrilling for Homer and for Mokena,” she said. “I can’t believe we won.” Four years ago, she ran unsuccessfully against Balich for the same seat.
Throughout her campaign, Boniecki-Cooling questioned Balich’s decisions and leadership during his tenure as Homer Township supervisor. She is not surprised by his recount request.
Balich has been a board member since 2012. He plans to review precincts for possible mistakes. “I expected a tight race, not a loss,” he stated. He believes many Republicans might have under-voted, only choosing Republican Leader Jim Richmond, who garnered 11,787 votes and was the top vote-getter in the district. Being first on the ballot might have benefited Richmond.
For Balich, this is not a first recount request. In 2024, he sought a recount after losing the precinct committeeperson race to Tami O’Brien by one vote. After a ballot was discarded, resulting in a tie, Balich won through a lottery.
If he loses again, Balich said he will accept the results. Should the results hold, Democrats will gain more control of the Will County Board, with 14 members to the Republicans’ 8. Most districts will be split between the parties, while three districts—covering Joliet, Romeoville, and Bolingbrook—will be represented by two Democrats each. No district will have two Republican representatives. The board often finds itself in a deadlock, with County Executive Jennifer Bertino-Tarrant, a Democrat, casting tie-breaking votes.
In a separate close race, Democrat Bob Howard, a former board member, increased his lead over incumbent Republican Judy Ogalla for District 2. This district includes New Lenox, Manhattan, Peotone, and eastern Will County. Current figures show Howard with 10,452 votes to Ogalla’s 10,174. Republican incumbent Frankie Pretzel from New Lenox received 13,361 votes.
Initially, Howard led Ogalla by only 81 votes on Election Night. After counting additional ballots, his lead expanded to 278 votes. Ogalla has served since 2012 and remarked that this margin is beyond recount parameters, acknowledging, “Either way, I win—fighting Democrats for two more years or reclaiming my life.” Ogalla stated her seat was targeted since the primary, with a candidate who frequently voted Democratic running as a Republican. She also reported receiving negative texts before the election.
Freelance reporter Michelle Mullins provided this report for the Daily Southtown.
