Caitlyn Jenner criticized a Seattle Times article on ‘America Reports’ for claiming there is ‘no serious scientific evidence’ that transgender athletes have a competitive advantage over biological women. Jenner, an Olympic gold medalist and Fox News contributor, joined co-anchor John Roberts to advocate for women’s sports, citing physical differences and her personal experiences in athletics.
The Seattle Times quickly reported after Nick Shirley, an independent journalist, retracted his accusation that Lam’s Seafood Asian Market in Seattle was involved in EBT fraud. The coverage was necessary as Shirley’s questionable claims risked damaging the family’s business reputation.
SEATTLE SCHOOL BOARD AUTHORIZES LEGAL CHALLENGE TO BALLOT MEASURE PROTECTING GIRLS’ SPORTS – JACKSON THOMPSON
Holding journalists accountable for errors is crucial. However, when the Seattle Times publishes disputable claims, the same standards should apply. The article featured athletes Frances Staudt, Bailey Andersen, and Sadie Sullivan, who shared their experiences at the Fairness in Girls’ Sports rally in Vancouver, Washington.
On November 8, the Times explored reasons for Washington voters supporting Initiative 638, which prohibits biological males from competing in K-12 girls’ sports. The article presented voices from both sides but included a paragraph asserting there’s no significant scientific evidence that transgender girls outmatched cisgender girls in athletics. This statement has faced criticism from multiple writers referencing scientific research suggesting advantages remain.
Conservative activist Riley Gaines mentioned a 2020 study of U.S. Air Force personnel finding transgender women 12% faster than biological females in a 1.5-mile run after two years of hormone treatment. Investigative journalist Benjamin Ryan shared a Substack essay linking to a 2025 study indicating lasting advantages in strength and size despite testosterone suppression. Karen Crouse, a Sport and State writer, cited a 2021 review showing strength and muscle size above female levels after three years of hormone therapy, as well as a 2023 American College of Sports Medicine report on performance advantages developed during male puberty.
Despite this evidence, the Times has not issued a retraction or clarification. The criticism is known, with Ryan noting a reporter acknowledged his feedback. Crouse reached out for clarification but received no reply. Emails sent to the Times’ editorial team went unanswered, raising concerns about whether the paper values serious evidence.
The article questions whether the Seattle Times risks losing credibility by publishing claims that contradict peer-reviewed research and ignoring criticism. Journalists must hold themselves accountable for publishing errors.
CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS APP
For opinions on the Seattle Times’ situation, you can reach Matthew Calkins at [email protected]. Matt Calkins writes for Outkick, focusing on sports and culture. Previously, he was a sports columnist for the Seattle Times and San Diego Union Tribune.
