Farm Life and Memories
Erin Moriarty interviewed Trysten Mullis at the Iowa farm where he grew up. He described nostalgic feelings with his siblings and parents who lived and worked on the 400-acre farm. The family raised soybeans, corn, and pigs in a collaborative effort.
The Day Amy Mullis Died
On a November morning in 2018, Amy Mullis appeared dizzy at the hog barn where she was cleaning light fixtures. After noticing her unease, Amy agreed to rest and retrieve a pet carrier from the red shed. Her son, Trysten, later found her on the ground with a corn rake in her back.
The 911 Call and Its Aftermath
Todd Mullis rushed Amy to the hospital, but she did not survive. Family members continue to grapple with the loss of Amy, described as vibrant and family-oriented.
Suspicion and Trial
Initially considered an accident, Amy’s death led to Todd’s arrest for murder. State Medical Examiner Dr. Kelly Kruse classified the death as homicide, citing multiple impalements. Todd Mullis’s trial revealed marital issues, including Amy’s affair and fears about divorce.
Defense and Testimony
Todd Mullis argued his innocence, claiming ignorance of the affair and denying murder accusations. His son Trysten initially provided an alibi but later admitted uncertainty about his father’s whereabouts.
Family Tension and Trysten’s Testimony
Trysten, pressured by family on trial testimony, accused step-grandfather Randy and a family attorney of influencing his statements. Living with Amy’s family was challenging due to conflicting beliefs about Todd’s guilt.
Seeking New Evidence
New attorneys investigated the case, presenting evidence suggesting Amy’s fall was accidental. Forensic experts argued her injuries were consistent with a fall on the rake.
Legal Appeals
Despite presenting new evidence, the judge denied Todd a new trial, citing fair trial conditions and calling Dr. Kruse credible. Todd’s family remains committed to rectifying the case, preparing for an appeal.
Determined to Fight
Trysten Mullis continues advocating for his father’s freedom and reflects on the loss of both parents. Convinced of Todd’s innocence, he vows to challenge the conviction with faith and perseverance.
Production credits and initial publication details omitted for clarity.