As a teenager, I dealt with court-imposed penalties, including a fine and community service. Ultimately, my record was expunged, allowing me to pursue higher education and work for Republican Congress members. This experience highlights a question Congress needs to consider: After meeting legal obligations, why should individuals face ongoing barriers?
Lawmakers seeking increased employment, family self-sufficiency, and better taxpayer outcomes should support the bipartisan Clean Slate Act. This legislation aims to remove barriers from federal arrest and conviction records, offering more Americans a chance to earn a living.
The Clean Slate Initiative’s report, “The Economic Losses from Arrest and Conviction Records,” reveals $440 billion in lost wages annually due to such records. The study indicates sustained employment and income disadvantages, even for those never convicted or without legal issues for over a decade. Individuals with arrest or non-conviction records lose an estimated $4,400 annually compared to peers without records. Those with nonviolent felony convictions face losses up to $9,300 annually. These figures are critical for families covering essentials or saving for future needs.
Lower earnings also lead to reduced spending in local economies. While the $440 billion figure includes records nationwide, beyond the federal scope of the Clean Slate Act, the data highlights the cost of not addressing these employment obstacles. Congress can tackle this by addressing the federal records system they oversee.
Consider a trained worker who applies for a job but hits an obstacle due to an outdated record. Policymakers need to remove the final hurdle as earnestly as they address workforce skills gaps. Employers deserve access to skilled candidates, and law-compliant individuals should compete for opportunities.
Job security is vital for facilitating second chances. Steady employment provides lawful income and necessary responsibilities. Encouraging stable lives helps prevent future criminal activity. Blanket exclusions can hinder this effort when an old record sheds little light on a person’s current behavior. Taxpayers are invested in the post-sentencing outcomes. We expect returning individuals to obey the law, seek employment, and support their families; the government should enable these goals by eliminating needless barriers.
Eligible records continuing to block applicants can undermine policies encouraging self-reliance. Congress should view record relief with the same practicality afforded other public safety laws: Does it keep individuals law-abiding? Fair earning opportunities should factor into this assessment.
The bipartisan Clean Slate Act, introduced by Reps. Lucy McBath (D-Ga.) and Nathaniel Moran (R-Texas) in the House and Sens. Lisa Blunt Rochester (D-Del.) and Rand Paul (R-Ky.) in the Senate, provides a sensible federal strategy. It would automate sealing for qualifying federal non-conviction records and certain drug convictions. The legislation includes a petition process for other records.
For those never convicted, clearing eligible arrest records emphasizes the presumption of innocence. The bill defines eligibility limits yet maintains access for specified law enforcement purposes. The automated process reduces paperwork burdens, ensuring consistent government relief.
Furthermore, the Fresh Start Act would aid states in enacting their own automated record sealing and expungement laws with federal grant support. Its reporting provisions would help verify implementation efficacy. Together, these acts address federal barriers while backing state efforts for relief.
From personal experience, I understand the value of a second chance. Congress should enact the Clean Slate and Fresh Start Acts to extend these opportunities, enabling individuals to utilize their skills, support their families, and build stable futures. Accountability must pave the way to contribution, and our legal framework should facilitate this path.
Reginald Darby is the federal affairs director at the Clean Slate Initiative and a former congressional staffer.
Copyright 2026 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.